Stratedge
    Back to all articles

    B2A's first casualty is the brand nobody sees

    By Barbara Cresti

    A customer asks an AI agent which product to buy. Five brands make the shortlist. The rest don't appear — without ever knowing they were competing. For CMOs, CCOs and CxOs, the rules of commercial strategy just changed.

    7 min read

    #Leadership & AI Strategy

    In October, Human Forward tested 75 established UK brands across six AI models. Fifteen never entered the conversation at all. Those 15 brands did not lose a sale they were competing for. They were absent from the competition altogether.

    This is the emerging B2A economy — business-to-agent. The term entered mainstream strategy vocabulary when Andreessen Horowitz used it to describe the dynamic in which AI agents, not human browsers, increasingly mediate purchasing decisions. The implications for brand, commercial and marketing leaders are structural, not tactical.

    The agent is already in the room

    The numbers are still small. On its Q3 2026 earnings call, Uber reported that agents placed roughly 500 Eats orders and four rides over Halloween week — out of 320 million total trips. United Airlines has since moved to block personal AI agents from completing bookings, citing customer data risk and unintended purchases. CEO Scott Kirby put it plainly: "I don't want to create another middleman."

    But trajectory and volume are different questions. BCG surveyed 150 retailers and brands in October 2026 and found that 68% expect agentic commerce to have a significant or transformational effect within two years. Forrester’s 2027 predictions estimate that AI agents will influence 75% of B2B purchase decisions. KPMG found that 65% of organisations now expect AI-collaboration skills to become standard job requirements.

    BCG’s parallel consumer-goods survey found that 59% of US consumer-goods companies report no meaningful agentic AI capabilities — even as nearly half of US consumers already shop with AI assistance. The agent is in the room. The question for CMOs and CCOs is whether their brand is on the list when it starts talking.

    68%

    of retailers expect agentic commerce to be significant or transformational within 2 years

    BCG, October 2026

    75%

    of B2B purchase decisions will be influenced by AI agents

    Forrester Predictions 2027

    15

    out of 75 established UK brands never appeared in AI agent conversations

    Human Forward, October 2026

    Brand influence isn’t disappearing — it’s moving upstream

    The prevailing assumption has been that AI agents will commoditise preference: by stripping away emotional cues and comparing on price and specification, they will gradually erode the commercial value of brand. The evidence suggests the opposite is happening.

    A 2026 experiment found that familiar brands won every test involving identical specifications. Product specifications accounted for 82.4% of the differences in how products were ranked — but brand recognition determined which products entered consideration in the first place. The agent does not start from a blank slate. It has absorbed the brand hierarchies encoded in its training data, and it reflects them.

    An instruction file extracted from Meta’s Muse shopping agent provides a concrete example: it was found to favour well-known brands among its top five recommendations. For challengers, this is the structural problem. Aggressive pricing offers no guarantee of consideration if the agent never surfaces the product. For incumbents, familiar brands win the shortlist — but only if their product data is accurate, structured and accessible enough for the agent to verify the advantage.

    Brand influence isn't disappearing. It is moving upstream — from the moment of comparison to the moment of consideration. Who controls the shortlist may matter more than who wins the comparison.

    The B2A dynamic also applies to B2B. Forrester’s research shows that autonomous agent buying is expected to concentrate first in high-volume, low-risk, repeat purchases — exactly the category where many B2B suppliers have historically competed on relationship and switching cost rather than on data quality and discoverability. That protection is weakening.

    82.4%

    of product ranking differences explained by product specifications — once a brand is in consideration

    2026 B2A experiment

    59%

    of US consumer-goods companies report no meaningful agentic AI capabilities

    BCG CPG survey, October 2026

    The commercial agenda has shifted

    The implications are concrete and immediate for CMOs, CCOs and the executives who oversee commercial strategy.

    Structured product data is now a commercial asset. An agent cannot recommend what it cannot read. Product information must be machine-readable, accurate and independently verifiable — not optimised solely for a human browsing a website. That means structured catalogues, schema markup, clean data feeds and verifiable claims that an agent can confirm against a third-party source.

    Brand investment must be justified differently. Boards and CFOs have always asked what brand spending returns. The B2A dynamic adds a new and measurable answer: brand recognition shapes shortlist entry. A brand absent from the agent's training data or from the sources the agent consults is structurally disadvantaged before price or quality is considered.

    Distribution and credibility are now commercial signals. The agent draws on what is authoritative and accessible. Credible distribution channels, verified ratings, independent editorial coverage and presence in the databases the agent consults are all inputs into selection. The CMO's remit now includes the data estate the brand occupies — not just the content it publishes.

    The real threat to brands is not losing the customer's choice. It is disappearing from the choices altogether. In B2A, commercial advantage increasingly begins before the comparison. The brand nobody sees cannot compete for the customer nobody sends.

    Frequently asked questions

    Get started

    Turn this insight into action.

    Book a 30-minute conversation with StratEdge to explore what this means for your Board, executive team or organisation.

    Book a meeting